SHU Poll: Affordability Drives Midterm Voting as Nearly Half Cite Opposition to Trump
Tri-state survey finds cost of living drove voting decisions, while nearly half say opposition to Trump was a factor in their congressional vote
Key Highlights
- A Sacred Heart University/GreatBlue Research post-election poll surveyed registered voters in Connecticut, New York, and New Jersey to examine the issues and motivations influencing the 2026 midterm elections
- Affordability was the leading issue influencing voters, with 38.9% identifying cost of living and affordability as the most important factor in their vote, compared with 13.9% who selected jobs and the economy
- 44.8% of registered voters said addressing the cost of living should be the first priority for newly elected officials
- SHU's earlier Connecticut gubernatorial polling series found that affordability steadily increased as voters' top concern, rising from 29.4% in July to 31.4% in September and 33.9% in October 2026
Affordability emerged as the leading issue influencing voters in the 2026 midterm elections, while opposition to President Donald Trump played a significant role in congressional voting decisions, according to a new Sacred Heart University post-election poll of registered voters in Connecticut, New York, and New Jersey.
The survey, conducted by SHU partner GreatBlue Research, found that nearly four in 10 voters (38.9%) identified cost of living and affordability as the single most important issue influencing their vote, far outpacing jobs and the economy (13.9%), housing costs (7.6%), health care (7.6%), and taxes (7.1%). With the election over, that concern remains at the forefront, as 44.8% of registered voters say affordability should be the first priority for newly elected officials.
The findings extend a central theme from Sacred Heart’s three-part Connecticut gubernatorial polling series with WFSB and CT Insider, which tracked voters’ concerns throughout the summer and fall. In July, 29.4% of Connecticut registered voters identified cost of living and inflation as their most important issue in deciding the governor's race. That figure increased to 31.4% in September and 33.9% in October.
Although the post-election survey includes voters from three states rather than Connecticut alone, the results reinforce that the affordability concerns measured throughout the campaign carried through to Election Day remain a priority for voters after the results are in.
“The post-election poll strongly suggests that voters want those who were elected to public office in 2026 to focus on cost-of-living issues,” said Gary Rose, SHU professor of political science & global affairs and scholar in residence. “Those issues include, among others, the cost of utilities, gas, groceries, and housing. Should the Democratic controlled Congress that will be sworn in on January 3, 2027, concentrate its attention on hearings and investigations of President Trump and members of his administration, rather than focusing on affordability, there could be political backlash against the Democrats in 2028; affordability must be a legislative priority especially with a much higher percentage of voters (49.8%) trusting the Democrats to solve this problem compared to Republicans (23.2%).”
Trump Opposition Plays Significant Role in Congressional Voting
While affordability dominated voters’ issue priorities, the survey also found that Trump was a significant factor in congressional voting decisions, particularly among those who said they voted to express opposition to him.
Nearly half of respondents who voted in the 2026 election (48.2%) said their congressional vote was intended to express opposition to Trump, compared with 14.8% who said their vote was intended to express support for him. Another 31.4% said Trump was not a factor in their congressional vote.
Opposition to Trump as a voting motivation was reported across all three states, including 50.9% of Connecticut voters, 50.4% of New Jersey voters, and 43.2% of New York voters.
The findings also reveal differences among political and demographic groups. Two-thirds of Democrats (67.0%) said opposition to Trump was a factor in their congressional vote, while 57.3% of voters ages 65 and older reported the same.
However, voters described their motivations differently when asked about the top statewide race on their ballot. A majority (57.8%) characterized their vote as primarily supporting their preferred candidate, while 20.4% said they were voting against another candidate, and 16% said their vote was primarily based on political party affiliation.
The results highlight a distinction between voters’ motivations in major statewide races and the national political dynamics influencing U.S. House contests. While most respondents described their vote in their top statewide race as a vote for their preferred candidate, nearly half said their House vote was intended, at least in part, to express opposition to Trump.
Voters Want Action on Affordability
Beyond the election results, the survey examined which political party voters trust more to address the financial challenges facing households.
Nearly half of registered voters (49.8%) said they trust the Democratic Party more to address cost-of-living concerns, compared with 23.2% who selected the Republican Party. The gap was particularly notable among independents: 40.5% expressed greater trust in Democrats on affordability, compared with 9.9% who selected Republicans, while 28.2% said they trust neither party.
That finding provides additional context for the election results: affordability was the leading issue influencing voters, and Democrats held a sizable advantage when respondents were asked which party they trust more to address it.
The survey also found that voters remain concerned about the direction of the country. More than six in 10 registered voters (60.8%) believe the nation is on the wrong track, compared with 25.9% who say it is headed in the right direction. Voters were less pessimistic about conditions closer to home, although 48.1% still believe their respective state is on the wrong track.
Despite those concerns, respondents expressed broad satisfaction with the election results. More than two-thirds (68.5%) reported being very or somewhat satisfied with the nationwide U.S. House election results. Among Connecticut and New York respondents, 66.4% expressed satisfaction with their respective gubernatorial election outcomes.
Voters were less unified, however, on what the election results actually represented. Just 28.7% viewed the outcome of their top statewide race as support for the winner's agenda, while 29.9% attributed it primarily to party-line voting, and 18.5% viewed it mainly as a rejection of the opposing candidate.
The findings offer a post-election look at the issues voters prioritized, the motivations behind their decisions, and the expectations they hold for newly elected leaders. Taken together, they suggest that while voters may differ on what the 2026 results mean politically, they are considerably clearer about the issue they want addressed next: the cost of living.
“The post-election poll also portends serious political problems going forward for the Republican party,” Rose said. “The poll found 60.4% of rural voters opposed to President Trump; substantially higher than suburban voters (48.1%) and urban voters (44.0%). With rural voters comprising the strongest component of the Republican party's coalition and because Trump has been the central figure within the GOP, it appears that Republicans have much work to do in the years ahead to regain the trust of rural voters and to rebuild the Republican brand in rural America.”
About the Poll
The Sacred Heart University/GreatBlue Research post-election poll surveyed 500 registered voters in Connecticut, New York, and New Jersey from November 4-5, 2026, using a digital survey methodology. The poll has a margin of error of plus or minus 4.4 percentage points at the 95% confidence level. The sample was weighted by age, gender, education, and political affiliation, with geographic representation across the three states.
The survey follows Sacred Heart University’s three-part Connecticut gubernatorial polling series with WFSB and CT Insider, conducted by GreatBlue Research in July, September, and October, which tracked voter priorities, attitudes toward state government and preferences in the 2026 governor's race.
Want to hear more from SHU? Subscribe to our Pioneer Times newsletter to get the latest updates delivered right to your inbox.